Coffee with dessert is the default, but at 8pm on Thanksgiving, half the table does not want caffeine. A pot of tea matched to the dessert is a small touch guests remember, and it keeps everyone at the table a little longer. Here is what to pour with every pie.
The pairing cheat sheet
- Pumpkin pie + Sunday Pancakes
- Apple pie + Autumn Breeze
- Pecan pie + Snow Angel
- Chocolate anything + Picnic in the Park
- Carrot cake + Road Trip
- Cheesecake + Apple Picking
How to pair tea with dessert
There are two ways to do it. You can match (spice with spice, apple with apple) for a cozy, layered bite, or you can contrast (something bright or minty to cut through something rich). Both work. The only rule: keep it caffeine-free at night.
What to serve with every Thanksgiving dessert
Pumpkin pie and Sunday Pancakes
Rooibos, banana, and maple sit right next to pumpkin and warm spice. It is a match: smooth, sweet, and cozy.
Apple pie and Autumn Breeze
Tulsi, cinnamon, and ginger bring out the spice in the filling. A seasonal blend that is running low, so stock up for the holiday.
Pecan pie and Snow Angel
Pecan pie is the richest thing on the table. Peppermint and spearmint cut right through it for a clean, refreshing finish.
Chocolate desserts and Picnic in the Park
Apple, hibiscus, and pomegranate add a bright, berry-like tartness that makes chocolate taste even richer. For a real treat, set out a Xocolatl dark chocolate raspberry bar alongside it.
Carrot cake and Road Trip
Road Trip already has carrot in it, along with ginger, turmeric, and pineapple. It is basically carrot cake in a mug.
Cheesecake and Apple Picking
Tangy hibiscus and sweet apple balance a creamy cheesecake. Our bestselling blend.
How to set up a dessert tea bar
- Fill the kettle before dinner so it is ready when the pies come out.
- Set out two or three canisters next to the desserts with a little card showing which pairs with which.
- Offer honey, lemon, and a little frothed milk for anyone who wants a latte.
- Put out pretty cups and pastel tea party napkins.
- Send guests home with a mini pack of their favorite.
Why order now
- Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26. Order now so your dessert tea bar is stocked in time.
- Autumn Breeze is seasonal and running low.
- Free shipping on orders over $60, so a canister plus a few mini packs ships free.
Frequently asked questions
What tea goes with pumpkin pie? A rooibos, maple, or spiced blend. Sunday Pancakes is our pick.
Should I serve tea or coffee with dessert? Why not both? Offering a caffeine-free tea means guests who want to sleep tonight still get a warm drink with dessert.
Love pairings? Try our tea and snack pairing guide.
